CommentStreams:322332be5c5a38df2d5802beaad91321

Single member guild is bad as things are now, with member losing medals when leaving the guild. Before that the foccus was to transfer medals from a lot of accounts to the guild with the main accounts of players using ghost accounts. A lot of ghost guilds ended up in top20 or top50? Yes, but that was more like collateral or greedy side quest, not the foccus. With leaving members loosing medals the foccus switched to making the ghost guilds to go all the way on points and win guilds rating season. I believe thats the reason we only have 1600+ guilds now (don't remember if we surpassed 2500 but I pretty sure we got more than 2000 when medal transfer galore was working), a lot of single member guild that was farming medals to transfer to main guilds were consolidated in hundreds less guilds with 8 members that would go all the way in to win season and just having main accounts entering the best placed ghost guilds at the end of season to take the prizes.

As for uncertainty making player opperating ghost accounts to take as many points as possible in as many ghost guilds as possible, and thus kicking all legit guilds out of top50, I agree with you. And is not just for the reason you stated, that a non cooperative guild(s) can spoil the scheme making ghost guilds loose as much as 30k (from 80k+ to 50+), but also that the guilds they initially chose to have 80k+ might be put to face each other and they will have to choose one of then to take 80k+ and the others to take less points and that chosen one might then face non cooperative guild in future war. Since it's not just one person using that tactic of ghosts, that may cost top3 win. So they take as much points as possible in as many guilds as possible to make sure they reach end of season with the most guilds with perfect 80k+ points in all 7 wars. But again, by doing so they kick out every normal legit guild out of top50.